Rigid v. Dewalt (Miter Saw)

topic posted Sun, January 2, 2005 - 2:30 PM by  Unsubscribed
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
I'm looking at a 12" Rigid miter, which comes with a laser and a clamp ($260), v Dewalt 12", no laser, no clamp ($299). Dewalt has a little taller rail.

Rigid is Home Depot's brand. I haven't found any reviews on-line. Any thoughts?

Would I be better off going for a 10"?
posted by:
Unsubscribed
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Unsu...
     

    Re: Rigid v. Dewalt (Miter Saw)

    Sun, January 2, 2005 - 4:00 PM
    depending on how much of a perfectionist you are, the laser may or may not be worth it. the choice here also depends on how hard you're gonna work the saw. I've used rigid tools from time to time w/ no durability problems, but dewalt still has a better reputation. As for the laser, ask to try it, if they'll let you. most lasers aren't as accurate as the old fashioned method of creeping up on a scribed line. they do make things faster though, and if you're not psycho-accurate, they're really cool.

    would you be better off with a 10", depends on what you're up to. I tend to get larger capacity tools by default, because of the "you never know when you'll need to" factor. This has payed off on a number of occasions. On the other hand, if you're not going to be cutting huge stock...

    you're questions are very application specific. Consider your applications carefully, and make your choice. If it was my money, I'd get whatever I could get by Bosch or DeWalt, with a laser if possible. I have a bias for German Engineering, but it's backed up by experience.
  • Re: Rigid v. Dewalt (Miter Saw)

    Sun, January 2, 2005 - 5:07 PM
    keep this in mind. the larger the blade, the more flex in the blade. there isnt any 12 in blade in the world worthy of stain grade crown. I use a hitachi 8 1/2 inch sliding mitre saw, and i swear by it. lasers are for the weak or at least people more concerned by gadgets than precision. that is my 2 cents
    • Unsu...
       

      Re: Rigid v. Dewalt (Miter Saw)

      Sun, January 2, 2005 - 5:16 PM
      will a 10" handle boards for cabinets and tables? would i need a double bevel to flip over the board if i have to make too cuts?
    • Unsu...
       

      Re: Rigid v. Dewalt (Miter Saw)

      Sun, January 2, 2005 - 5:28 PM
      what are the benefits of a sliding miter?
      • Re: Rigid v. Dewalt (Miter Saw)

        Sun, January 2, 2005 - 11:07 PM
        oh goodness....well, almost every brand has some king of sliding compound mitre saw. here in seattle at least, they are the industry standard. being a career carpenter specializing in top end residential finish carpentry, i have been on lots of jobs. the hitachi 8 1/2 in is the one i see the most of. having tested all of the proffessional grade saws out there, i agree that it has superior fit and finish, with a thick kerf saw blade it is reliable for production, perfection quality cutting of all kinds. that is why it is pretty much the industry standard chot saw for finish carpenter. crosscutting of some pretty wide materials is possible by drawing aling line across the board and flipping the piece to finish the cut. my favorite advantage of a slide say is that you can actually draw the blade across the board to see where it is going to cut. that is especially convient for cuts that need to be at a certain angle other than square. you are allowed mulltiple passes, and to control the direction of the teeth during your cut as to minimize tear out. you can rip shim pacs with it by CAREFULLY flipping a board over everytime after a cut almost the way through at oh say ..5 degrees. some saws flip over, mine dosent, but most others do, i have used the bosch 10 in, and i like it it is more durable than the rest the hitachi 10 in feels good, but the blade is just too big for me to feel comfortable with. I use a 10 non slide sar for very few things....makes a good back up for cutting 4x4's and that is about it, sometimes comes in handy, but the wobble in 12 in blades is really annoying when doing ultra fine work. if i had to pick, id take a slide saw every time,

        there is my opinion, i hope it is helpfull
        ~M
  • Re: Rigid v. Dewalt (Miter Saw)

    Mon, January 3, 2005 - 11:05 AM
    I have heard several people say that the lasers eventually go out of alignment, and then they become more of an annoyance than a help. They're yet another gadget that you pay for because they look cool, but you wind up not really using.
  • RK
    RK
    offline 37

    Re: Rigid v. Dewalt (Miter Saw)

    Sat, February 26, 2005 - 11:47 PM
    If you knew that Dewalt was made by Black and Decker would you still pay that much for it?
    • Re: Rigid v. Dewalt (Miter Saw)

      Sat, February 26, 2005 - 11:59 PM
      dewalt...yuck...i am biased against them, except for the new surface planer they are making, it seems that they spend more money sponsoring race cars and rodeos than they do in r and d....well, some of their stuff is good, i know that i have killed way too many of their cordless drills to get another.i have a 12 in slide for some reason,it is a good tool, but i rarely but i rarely ever use it. i guess i just have a major love affair with my hitachi slide saw, actually, someone brought their brand new 10 rigid compound mitre saw to the job last week, and...well....it seems pretty good, pretty tight, and worked well....i guess we will see how it does over the long haul. i am pretty impressed with a lot of rigids stuff, seems to be a pretty good buy for the money for jobsite portable stuff..........

Recent topics in "Fine Woodworking"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
my work bob 0 August 10, 2009
my inlay bob 0 August 4, 2009
Winter Projects? Unsubscribed 7 February 22, 2007
two things gorma cu 0 January 8, 2007